Few gemstones can rival the hypnotic beauty of opal. With its kaleidoscope of shifting colours, every opal feels like holding a tiny galaxy in your hand. But if you’ve ever tried to buy an opal, you’ve probably noticed something confusing — prices can range from under £50 to well over £10,000 for a single stone.
So, how exactly are opal stones graded and valued? What makes one more precious than another? In this ultimate guide, we’ll break down the factors that determine an opal’s worth, explain the different types, and help you understand what to look for before making a purchase.
Whether you’re an avid gem collector, jewellery lover, or just curious about what makes opal so special, this guide is here to make sure all your questions are answered.
What Is Opal?
Opal is a hydrated form of silica — a mineral made from silicon and oxygen — that contains up to 21% water. Unlike most gemstones, which have a crystalline structure, opal is amorphous, meaning its atoms are arranged randomly.
What makes opal so mesmerising is its play-of-colour — that shifting rainbow effect that dances across the surface when light hits it. This happens because of microscopic silica spheres inside the stone, which diffract light into different colours (like a prism).
According to the Gemological Institute of America (GIA), Australia produces about 90% of the world’s opal, particularly from Lightning Ridge, Coober Pedy, and Andamooka. Other key sources include Ethiopia, Mexico, and Brazil, each producing unique varieties with distinct colour patterns.
What Are the Types of Opal?
Not all opals are created equal — and understanding the types is the first step to knowing how they’re valued.
1. Black Opal
Often considered the king of opals, black opal has a dark body tone that makes its colours pop dramatically. Found mainly in Lightning Ridge, Australia, these stones are the rarest and most valuable type. High-quality specimens can sell for over £10,000 per carat.
2. White Opal
Also known as “milky opal,” this type has a pale or white background colour. While it still shows play-of-colour, the effect is softer and less vivid. White opals are beautiful and more affordable, making them popular for everyday jewellery.
3. Boulder Opal
Boulder opal forms within ironstone rock, often leaving natural patterns where the opal and host rock meet. These are highly sought after for their earthy, organic appearance and durability.
4. Crystal Opal
Crystal opal is semi-transparent to transparent with vibrant internal colour play. Its clarity gives it an ethereal, glowing look that collectors love.
5. Fire Opal
Unlike other types, fire opal (mostly from Mexico) doesn’t always show play-of-colour. Instead, it’s valued for its vivid orange, red, or yellow body tone.
6. Common Opal (Potch)
This variety lacks the play-of-colour entirely but can still be lovely in pastel shades like pink, blue, or green. It’s typically more affordable and used in decorative or bead jewellery.
Which Type of Opal Is More Expensive?
The most expensive and rarest type of opal is black opal, specifically those from Lightning Ridge, Australia. These stones display a dark background with fiery colour patterns that seem to glow from within.
In 2022, a rare 98-carat black opal known as “The Eternal Flame” was valued at over £650,000, showing just how prized top-quality specimens can be.
The hierarchy of value generally goes like this:
Black Opal → Boulder Opal → Crystal Opal → White Opal → Fire Opal → Common Opal
Of course, within each category, individual stones can vary widely in price depending on their quality factors (which we’ll explore next).
How Are Opals Valued?
Grading opal isn’t as straightforward as grading diamonds or sapphires. Instead, it relies on a combination of colour, pattern, brilliance, transparency, and overall appearance. Let’s break down the main factors:
1. Colour Play and Brightness
The most important factor in an opal’s value is its play-of-colour — the range, intensity, and visibility of colours across the surface.
-
Stones showing multiple bright colours (especially reds, oranges, and violets) are the most valuable.
-
According to the Opal Association of Australia, red flashes are the rarest, while green and blue are more common.
2. Pattern
The arrangement of colours matters too. Desirable patterns include Harlequin, Pinfire, and Flame — all of which show distinct, vibrant colour patches.
3. Body Tone
The background colour of the opal (from black to white) affects how visible the play-of-colour appears. Darker body tones usually fetch higher prices because they enhance contrast.
4. Transparency
Crystal and semi-crystal opals, which are translucent, can be very valuable if they display vibrant internal colours.
5. Cut and Shape
A well-cut opal maximises the visible colour play and symmetry. Cabochon cuts (smooth, rounded domes) are the most common for opals.
6. Size and Carat Weight
Larger opals can be dramatically more valuable, especially if the colour quality remains consistent across the stone.
7. Origin
Australian opals generally command higher prices due to their quality and consistency, but Ethiopian and Mexican opals are gaining recognition for their unique appearances.
Fun Fact: According to jewellery market data, opal prices have increased by over 30% since 2018 due to rising global demand and limited mining output.
Buying Tips: What to Look for in Opal Stones
If you’re planning to buy an opal, focus on stones that:
-
Show consistent colour play from multiple angles.
-
Have vivid, bright flashes (not dull or cloudy).
-
They are well-polished and free from visible cracks.
Always buy from reputable jewellers or gem dealers who can provide origin details and authenticity certificates.
Conclusion
Opal is one of the most captivating gemstones in the world — a true masterpiece of nature. Its value comes from a perfect mix of colour, rarity, and individuality. No two opals are the same, making every stone as unique as the person who wears it.
Whether you’re investing in a black opal masterpiece or choosing a delicate white opal pendant, understanding how these stones are graded helps you make an informed and confident purchase.
So next time you admire an opal’s shimmering spectrum, you’ll know exactly what makes it so precious.
FAQs
1. What makes opal valuable?
Opal’s value depends on its colour play, brightness, body tone, and rarity. Black opals with vivid multi-colour flashes are typically the most expensive.
2. Is opal rarer than diamonds?
In some cases, yes — fine-quality black opals are significantly rarer than diamonds.
3. Are opals good for everyday wear?
Opals are softer than most gems (5.5–6.5 on the Mohs scale), so they require gentle care. It’s best to wear them in protective settings or for special occasions.
4. Do opals lose colour over time?
Not if properly cared for. However, exposure to heat or very dry environments can cause cracking or dullness.
5. Should I invest in opal stones?
Yes, high-quality opals — especially Australian black opals — have shown steady value growth and are considered excellent collector’s items.